Monday 26 December 2011

Doctor Who - The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe

This review can also be found on Step2Inspire.

BANG! That was the quite literal sound of Christmas being made for many, if not all, Whovians, as that legendary Time Lord – the Doctor – returned to Earth for his annual festive jaunt through time and space.

Last seen marrying his would-be killer and faking his death on the shore of Lake Silencio (and then flogging his stylish tweed jacket and bow tie on telly for Children in Need... Hardly keeping a low profile!), the Doctor is still alive and well and running around big exploding space ships that are threatening to destroy the Earth. However, this pyrotechnic opening was merely the introduction to a less explosive adventure set in a wintry forest, inside a box in a living room, with tree spirits, the Green Man and his misses, and Bill Bailey...

In the midst of the second World War, Madge (Claire Skinner), a mother of two, finds herself widowed shortly before Christmas when her husband (Alexander Armstrong) crashes attempting to pilot his damaged plane across the channel. Without the heart to tell her kids about their father's fate so close to Christmas, and having to evacuate London to the safety of the countryside, Madge tries to stay strong in the face of hardship. Arriving at their new country-house residence, Madge, Cyril and Lily meet the eccentric care-taker – known to many as the Doctor. In an effort to make their Christmas the best one ever, the Doctor has kitted out the 1940's country-house with an array of weird and wonderful quirks, not least the inter-dimensional portal to a Christmassy forest cunningly disguised as a rather large present. However, overcome by the temptation to take a peak at what's inside the impossible box, Cyril inquisitively wanders into this strange and distant world alone, where something has disturbed the trees of this mystical forest...

Loosely based on The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe was certainly fairly Narnia-esque, but with a very different story. It had a kind of fairy tale feel about it – a well told narrative of magic and wonder, and the fate of the Universe didn't hang in the balance. The main threat was to the happiness of one family at Christmas, and an alien forest that's facing imminent destruction at the hands of the environmentally unscrupulous harvesters of Androzani Major. It may not have been quite as big a spectacle as the likes of A Good Man Goes To War or The Wedding of River Song, but it was an enjoyable family tale nonetheless.

Matt Smith's performance was as fantastically eccentric and mad as ever, but the star of this particular episode had to be Claire Skinner. As both a heart-broken widow and strong and resilient mother (and saviour of an entire race of trees), she masterfully balanced the various aspects of her character, mourning the loss of her husband but also keeping it together to rescue her children. Any woman who isn't phased by a strange man in a back-to-front space suit, and then proceeds to drive him around looking for a time travelling police box, then three years later loses her husband in the war and her children in a forest inside a box, and still manages to take it all in her stride is not only an incredibly strong individual, but also a perfect candidate for the TARDIS crew! As for the rest of the cast; Bill Bailey, Arabella Weir and Paul Bazely made an appearance, but it was far too fleeting in my opinion, and could've done with a bit more from the polluting space marines – who, for all their industrious virtues, have scanning devices that can easily be fooled by a cardigan (and apparently sonic screwdrivers still can't do wood – I think the people of the future need to better hone their technology!).

I did feel that the Green Man's acting was a little wooden, though... Probably best he sticks to tending to nature and naming pubs in the future.

Overall, whilst this may not have been the most exciting of episodes for Doctor Who, it was nevertheless a brilliant adventure for the festive season. With the rather miraculous and warm ending to Madge's story, followed by the brief cameo of Amy and Rory inviting the Doctor in for dinner, there was indeed an air of the Christmas spirit about it.
But alas, that's it from the Doctor until Autumn 2012 – well, it's been a busy year for the Time Lord! If you missed the Christmas special, it's available on BBC iPlayer here.

No comments:

Post a Comment